Are Boards of Review Scrutinizing Appraisal Evidence More Closely?
A recent study from a county Assessor’s Office revealed a striking statistic: commercial appeal appraisals averaged just 62% of actual sale prices. As a result, that figure is now being used to support a growing critique, that unsupported reductions may be shifting tax burdens onto homeowners.
Because of this, Boards of Review are facing subtle but real pressure to scrutinize appraisal evidence more closely. In turn, professionals involved in appeals are beginning to notice changes in how valuation arguments are received.
A Quiet Change, But a Real One
While no formal policy changes have been announced, the shift is still noticeable. In fact, several property tax attorneys and valuation professionals report the same underlying theme: the tone has changed.
Previously, strong legal arguments often carried significant weight on their own. Now, however, Boards are asking deeper questions about valuation methodology, assumptions, and market support. As a result, conclusions that lack clear backing are receiving increased scrutiny.
For appeal filers, this matters, a lot.
Why Appraisal Quality Suddenly Matters More
As appraisal credibility comes under closer review, Boards are under greater pressure to protect the integrity of the tax base. Consequently, unsupported or overly aggressive valuations are less likely to pass without challenge.
For example, income assumptions, comparable sales selection, and adjustment logic are all being examined more closely. In other words, appraisal quality is no longer secondary, it is central to appeal success.
In short, strong legal arguments now require equally strong valuation backing to achieve the same outcomes they once did.
What This Means for the 2026 Appeal Cycle
As we move deeper into the 2026 appeal cycle, this shift has real implications:
-
-
- Appeals relying on thin or recycled appraisals may struggle
- Boards may expect clearer reconciliation between approaches
- Sale-price disconnects will draw attention — fast
- Credibility, not just persuasion, will drive results
-
If you’re already reinforcing your valuation strategy, you’re ahead of the curve. If not, now is the time to reassess before filings are underway.
How to Strengthen Your Valuation Strategy Right Now
To stay competitive in this evolving environment, consider:
-
-
- Using sale-supported conclusions wherever possible
- Clearly explaining deviations from recent transactions
- Tightening income and expense assumptions to market norms
- Ensuring appraisal narratives can withstand Board-level scrutiny
-
For broader context on appraisal standards and defensible valuation practices, the Appraisal Institute’s guidance on commercial valuation methodology remains a trusted reference and can support credibility in appeals when cited appropriately.
Boards are paying closer attention, are your appraisals ready?
If you’re preparing for the 2026 appeal cycle and want appraisal evidence that holds up under increased scrutiny, now is the time to act.
Don’t let weak valuation evidence undermine your appeal, use appraisal support designed to hold up under Board scrutiny.